Music Review: Josiah Leming – Angels Under Cover (EP)

Hey all…

When Josiah Leming appeared in American Idol during Season 7, all of us at my house were rooting for him. His story was compelling, a kid on his own on the road, simply trying to make his music. So when he was booted during Hollywood Week, we were bummed.

Now he has a new album that came out in January 2009 — Angels Undercover. This album contains five songs he’s written and performed, including “To Run”, which he played during his time on American Idol.

Here’s my only problem with Leming. His unique sound (with sort of a British pop voice from the 1960s) begins to sound very whiny after a while. The first time I listened to this EP, the speakers made him sound extremely tinny, which I attribute to the lack of significant bass in my car speaker setup. But once I played the album on a better stereo at home, the bass reduced the whiny/tinny nature to the point where I could enjoy the music.

By far, my favorite songs on the EP tell stories. “This Cigar” is the best on the CD. It tells the story of the transition we all face as we grow up. He’s told that all winners smoke cigars, but he avoids cigarettes and alcohol. It burns a hole in his pocket and he’s constantly defending himself against these bad “cigar” type influences as he earns his way along. It ends with a great a capella segment that shows his skills at arranging as well as songwriting.

My other favorite on the album is still “To Run” – the song that really won our hearts during his time on American Idol. It’s been fine tuned a bit since then, but the core is still there. It tells the story of his pursuit of a girl that doesn’t go well, leaving him trying to figure out where to run.

I truly hope the album does well for Leming. His story is worth hearing. Born in East Tennessee into a big family (4 brothers, 4 sisters), and a mother and father who worked hard to put food on the table. Josiah started teaching himself how to play piano at age 8, and received some help from a local piano instructor. He started writing his own tunes about age 16, and dropped out of school at age 17 to spend a year traveling and improving his performance and songwriting skills.

The album had a bit of controversy back in October 2008 when 19 Entertainment, producer of the entertainment coming out of such shows as American Idol, So you think You Can Dance, and Pop Idol in the UK. Leming was signed with Warner Brothers, which evidently (according to 19 Entertainment) violates the agreement Leming signed when he participated on Idol, which stipulates that he must record with Sony/BMG.

Evidently that dispute has been resolved, as his album was released in January even though it was originally supposed to release back in October 2008.

Angels Under Cover shows that Leming has promise. He’s a great songwriter with a good voice. That combined with his story should hopefully propel him towards a good career.

Track Listing:
1. Arctic Outcry Wind
2. Angels Undercover
3. Theysay
4. This Cigar
5. To Run

Until next time


p.s. Pick up this album at your local retailer or at Amazon:

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


  1. Very nice review. I’m also a big fan of Josiah’s, though I actually like Angels Undercover best.

    At any rate, just FYI, the info is not quite right in the review. This EP is not the album which is the result of the controversy… mainly by way of this not being an album.

    The album isn’t out yet, and the latest I’ve heard is that it is supposed to come out in March. As far as I know there is still some legal back and forth going on.

    Marc Eastmans last blog post..ScreenTime With Casey McKinnon – @caseymckinnon

  2. @Marc Eastman – Thanks for the feedback! Interesting about the EP not being the album (I’d like to hear more), but I’m not shocked there’s still some legal struggles over this one. You’d think that 19 Entertainment and the American Idol folks have more to do than spend money on lawyers over this. Though it gets them some publicity, I’m not sure it helps anybody in this case!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.